"Ingredients for life revealed in meteorites that fell to earth" by Glenn Roberts Jr, a Berkeley Lab News Release of January 10, 2018

I read your fine article with great interest. From my work on the periodicity of the atomic elements, it became clear to me that our sun was once an earth just like our own planet. It follows that the meteorites and other solar system debris which orbits the sun were once integral parts of that selfsame sun. So I am not even a bit surprised that such evidence as that described in your article exists. I am delighted that it has been found. It confirms the conclusion that so obviously presented itself in my work.


Robert William Whitby